NFL Comparisons

NFL Comparisons

Jim Brown vs Walter Payton Comparison

by Leave a Comment

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Jim Brown

Check/Uncheck

Walter Payton

 

Info

Teams

Jim Brown Cleveland Browns (1957-1965)
Walter Payton Chicago Bears (1975-1987)

Position

Jim Brown Running Back
Walter Payton Running Back

Height

Jim Brown 6'2"
Walter Payton 5'10"

Weight

Jim Brown 232
Walter Payton 200

Drafted

Jim Brown By the Browns in the 1st Round (6th Overall) in the 1957 Draft
Walter Payton By the Bears in the 1st Round (4th Overall) in the 1975 Draft

Super Bowls

Super Bowl Wins

Jim Brown 1 (1964* NFL Championship) Star
Walter Payton 1 (XX) Star

Super Bowl Appearances

Jim Brown 3 (1957*, 1964*-1965* NFL Championship Game) StarStarStar
Walter Payton 1 (1986) Star

Playoff Appearances

Playoff Appearances

Jim Brown 4 (1957-1958, 1964-1965) StarStarStarStar
Walter Payton 6 (1977, 1979, 1984-1987) StarStarStarStarStarStar

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Jim Brown Yes Inducted in 1971
Walter Payton Yes Inducted in 1993

Number Retired

Jim Brown Yes Browns #32
Walter Payton Yes Bears #34

NFL MVP

Jim Brown 4 (1957-1958, 1963, 1965) StarStarStarStar
Walter Payton 2 (1977, 1985) StarStar

Pro Bowl

Jim Brown 9 (1957–1965) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Walter Payton 9 (1976-1980, 1983-1986) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar

First Team All-Pro

Jim Brown 8 (1957-1961, 1963-1965) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Walter Payton 7 (1976-1980, 1984-1985) StarStarStarStarStarStarStar

Second Team All-Pro

Jim Brown 0
Walter Payton 1 (1986) Star

NFL Rushing Yards Leader

Jim Brown 8 (1957-1961, 1963-1965) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Walter Payton 1 (1977) Star

NFL Rushing Touchdown Leader

Jim Brown 5 (1957-1959, 1963, 1965) StarStarStarStarStar
Walter Payton 1 (1977) Star

Regular Season Stats

Games (G)

Jim Brown 118
Walter Payton 190

Games Started (GS)

Jim Brown 118
Walter Payton 184

Rushing Attempts (Att)

Jim Brown 2,359
Walter Payton 3,838

Rushing Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown 12,312
Walter Payton 16,726

Rushing Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown 106
Walter Payton 110

Rushing Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown 104.3
Walter Payton 88.0

Rushing Attempts per Game (A/G)

Jim Brown 20.0
Walter Payton 20.2

Rushing Yards per Attempt (Y/A)

Jim Brown 5.2
Walter Payton 4.4

Receptions (Rec)

Jim Brown 262
Walter Payton 492

Receiving Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown 2,499
Walter Payton 4,538

Yards per Reception (Y/R)

Jim Brown 9.5
Walter Payton 9.2

Receiving Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown 20
Walter Payton 15

Receptions per Game (R/G)

Jim Brown 2.2
Walter Payton 2.6

Receiving Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown 21.2
Walter Payton 23.9

Yards from Scrimmage (YScm)

Jim Brown 14,811
Walter Payton 21,264

Fumbles

Jim Brown 57
Walter Payton 86

Playoff Stats

Games (G)

Jim Brown 4
Walter Payton 9

Games Started (GS)

Jim Brown 4
Walter Payton 9

Rushing Attempts (Att)

Jim Brown 66
Walter Payton 180

Rushing Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown 241
Walter Payton 632

Rushing Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown 1
Walter Payton 2

Rushing Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown 60.3
Walter Payton 70.2

Rushing Attempts per Game (A/G)

Jim Brown 16.5
Walter Payton 20

Rushing Yards per Attempt (Y/A)

Jim Brown 3.7
Walter Payton 3.5

Receptions (Rec)

Jim Brown 8
Walter Payton 22

Receiving Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown 99
Walter Payton 178

Yards per Reception (Y/R)

Jim Brown 12.4
Walter Payton 8.1

Receiving Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown 0
Walter Payton 0

Receptions per Game (R/G)

Jim Brown 2
Walter Payton 2.4

Receiving Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown 24.8
Walter Payton 19.8

Yards from Scrimmage (YScm)

Jim Brown 340
Walter Payton 810

Fumbles

Jim Brown 0
Walter Payton 4

Best Season Stats

Games (G)

Jim Brown 14 (1965)
Walter Payton 16 (1986)

Games Started (GS)

Jim Brown 14 (1965)
Walter Payton 16 (1986)

Rushing Attempts (Att)

Jim Brown 305 (1961)
Walter Payton 381 (1984)

Rushing Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown 1863 (1963)
Walter Payton 1852 (1977)

Rushing Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown 17 (1965)
Walter Payton 14 (1979)

Longest Rushing Attempt (Lng)

Jim Brown 80 (1963)
Walter Payton 76 (1978)

Rushing Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown 133.1 (1963)
Walter Payton 132.3 (1977)

Rushing Attempts per Game (A/G)

Jim Brown 24.2 (1959)
Walter Payton 24.2 (1977)

Rushing Yards per Attempt (Y/A)

Jim Brown 6.4 (1963)
Walter Payton 5.5 (1977)

Receptions (Rec)

Jim Brown 47 (1962)
Walter Payton 53 (1983)

Receiving Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown 517 (1962)
Walter Payton 607 (1983)

Yards per Reception (Y/R)

Jim Brown 11.2 (1963)
Walter Payton 11.5 (1983)

Receiving Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown 5 (1962)
Walter Payton 3 (1986)

Longest Reception (Lng)

Jim Brown 83 (1963)
Walter Payton 75 (1977)

Receptions per Game (R/G)

Jim Brown 3.4 (1962)
Walter Payton 3.6 (1982)

Receiving Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown 36.9 (1962)
Walter Payton 37.9 (1983)

Yards from Scrimmage (YScm)

Jim Brown 2131 (1963)
Walter Payton 2121 (1977)

Fumbles

Jim Brown 2 (1959)
Walter Payton 3 (1982)

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Jim Brown

Check/Uncheck

Walter Payton

 

Info

Teams

Jim Brown Cleveland Browns (1957-1965)
Walter Payton Chicago Bears (1975-1987)

Position

Jim Brown Running Back
Walter Payton Running Back

Height

Jim Brown 6'2"
Walter Payton 5'10"

Weight

Jim Brown 232
Walter Payton 200

Drafted

Jim Brown By the Browns in the 1st Round (6th Overall) in the 1957 Draft
Walter Payton By the Bears in the 1st Round (4th Overall) in the 1975 Draft

Super Bowls

Super Bowl Wins

Jim Brown 1 (1964* NFL Championship)
Walter Payton 1 (XX)

Super Bowl Appearances

Jim Brown 3 (1957*, 1964*-1965* NFL Championship Game)
Walter Payton 1 (1986)

Playoff Appearances

Playoff Appearances

Jim Brown 4 (1957-1958, 1964-1965)
Walter Payton 6 (1977, 1979, 1984-1987)

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Jim Brown Yes Inducted in 1971
Walter Payton Yes Inducted in 1993

Number Retired

Jim Brown Yes Browns #32
Walter Payton Yes Bears #34

NFL MVP

Jim Brown 4 (1957-1958, 1963, 1965)
Walter Payton 2 (1977, 1985)

Pro Bowl

Jim Brown 9 (1957–1965)
Walter Payton 9 (1976-1980, 1983-1986)

First Team All-Pro

Jim Brown 8 (1957-1961, 1963-1965)
Walter Payton 7 (1976-1980, 1984-1985)

Second Team All-Pro

Jim Brown 0
Walter Payton 1 (1986)

NFL Rushing Yards Leader

Jim Brown 8 (1957-1961, 1963-1965)
Walter Payton 1 (1977)

NFL Rushing Touchdown Leader

Jim Brown 5 (1957-1959, 1963, 1965)
Walter Payton 1 (1977)

Regular Season Stats

Games (G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Games Started (GS)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Attempts (Att)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Attempts per Game (A/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Yards per Attempt (Y/A)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receptions (Rec)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receiving Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Yards per Reception (Y/R)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receiving Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receptions per Game (R/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receiving Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Yards from Scrimmage (YScm)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Fumbles

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Playoff Stats

Games (G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Games Started (GS)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Attempts (Att)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Attempts per Game (A/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Rushing Yards per Attempt (Y/A)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receptions (Rec)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receiving Yards (Yds)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Yards per Reception (Y/R)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receiving Touchdowns (TD)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receptions per Game (R/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Receiving Yards per Game (Y/G)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Yards from Scrimmage (YScm)

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Fumbles

Jim Brown Walter Payton

Who do you think is the better player?

Who do you think is the better player?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...