• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

NFL Comparisons

NFL Comparisons

  • Home
  • MLB Comparisons
  • NBA Comparisons
  • CFB Comparisons
  • CBB Comparisons
  • More
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Links
    • Privacy Policy

Bart Starr vs Eli Manning Comparison

by Leave a Comment

0
SHARES
ShareTweet
  • Stats
  • Graphs

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Bart Starr

Check/Uncheck

Eli Manning

 

Info

Teams

Bart Starr Green Bay Packers (1956-1971)
Eli Manning New York Giants (2004-2019)

Position

Bart Starr Quarterback
Eli Manning Quarterback

Height

Bart Starr 6'1"
Eli Manning 6'4"

Weight

Bart Starr 197
Eli Manning 218

Drafted

Bart Starr By the Packers in the 17th Round (200th Overall) in the 1956 Draft
Eli Manning By the San Diego Chargers in the 1st Round (1st Overall) in the 2004 Draft

Super Bowls

Super Bowl Wins

Bart Starr 5 (5 NFL Championships 1961-1962, 1965-1967 and 2 Super Bowls I, II) StarStarStarStarStar
Eli Manning 2 (XLII, XLVI) StarStar

Super Bowl Appearances

Bart Starr 6 (1960-1962, 1965-1967) StarStarStarStarStarStar
Eli Manning 2 (2008, 2012) StarStar

Playoff Appearances

Playoff Appearances

Bart Starr 6 (1960-1962, 1965-1967) StarStarStarStarStarStar
Eli Manning 6 (2005-2008, 2011, 2016) StarStarStarStarStarStar

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Bart Starr Yes Inducted in 1977
Eli Manning No Still Playing

NFL MVP

Bart Starr 1 (1966) Star
Eli Manning 0

Super Bowl MVP

Bart Starr 2 (I, II) StarStar
Eli Manning 2 (XLII, XLVI) StarStar

Pro Bowl

Bart Starr 4 (1960-1962, 1966) StarStarStarStar
Eli Manning 4 (2008, 2011, 2012, 2015) StarStarStarStar

First Team All-Pro

Bart Starr 1 (1966) Star
Eli Manning 0

NFL Passing Touchdown Leader

Bart Starr 0
Eli Manning 0

NFL Passing Yards Leader

Bart Starr 0
Eli Manning 0

Completion Percentage Leader

Bart Starr 4 (1962, 1966, 1968-1969) StarStarStarStar
Eli Manning 0

QB Rating Leader

Bart Starr 4 (1964, 1966, 1968-1969) StarStarStarStar
Eli Manning 0

NFL Offensive Player of the Year

Bart Starr 0
Eli Manning 0

Regular Season Stats

Games (G)

Bart Starr 196
Eli Manning 232

Games Started (GS)

Bart Starr 157
Eli Manning 230

Pass Completions (Cmp)

Bart Starr 1,808
Eli Manning 4,804

Passing Attempts (Att)

Bart Starr 3,149
Eli Manning 7,972

Completion Percentage (Cmp%)

Bart Starr 57.4
Eli Manning 60.3

Passing Yards (Yds)

Bart Starr 24,718
Eli Manning 55,981

Touchdown Passes (TD)

Bart Starr 152
Eli Manning 360

Touchdown Percentage (TD%)

Bart Starr 4.8%
Eli Manning 4.5%

Interceptions Thrown (Int)

Bart Starr 138
Eli Manning 239

Interception Percentage (INT%)

Bart Starr 4.4
Eli Manning 3.0

Game Winning Drives (GWD)

Bart Starr 18
Eli Manning 42

Yards per Pass Attempt (Y/A)

Bart Starr 7.8
Eli Manning 7.0

Adjusted Yards per Pass Attempt (AY/A)

Bart Starr 6.8
Eli Manning 6.6

Yards Gained per Pass Completion (Y/C)

Bart Starr 13.7
Eli Manning 11.7

Yards Gained per Games Played (Y/G)

Bart Starr 126.1
Eli Manning 241.3

QB Rating (Rate)

Bart Starr 80.5
Eli Manning 84.1

Playoff Stats

Games (G)

Bart Starr 10
Eli Manning 12

Games Started (GS)

Bart Starr 10
Eli Manning 12

Pass Completions (Cmp)

Bart Starr 130
Eli Manning 242

Passing Attempts (Att)

Bart Starr 213
Eli Manning 400

Completion Percentage (Cmp%)

Bart Starr 61.0
Eli Manning 60.5

Passing Yards (Yds)

Bart Starr 1,753
Eli Manning 2,815

Touchdown Passes (TD)

Bart Starr 15
Eli Manning 18

Interceptions Thrown (Int)

Bart Starr 3
Eli Manning 9

QB Rating (Rate)

Bart Starr 104.9
Eli Manning 87.5

Best Season Stats

Games (G)

Bart Starr 14 (1970)
Eli Manning 16 (2019)

Games Started (GS)

Bart Starr 14 (1965)
Eli Manning 16 (2019)

Touchdown Passes (TD)

Bart Starr 16 (1965)
Eli Manning 35 (2016)

Passing Yards (Yds)

Bart Starr 2438 (1962)
Eli Manning 4933 (2012)

Interceptions Thrown (Int)

Bart Starr 3 (1971)
Eli Manning 5

Pass Completions (Cmp)

Bart Starr 178 (1962)
Eli Manning 387 (2016)

Passing Attempts (Att)

Bart Starr 295 (1961)
Eli Manning 618 (2016)

Completion Percentage (Cmp%)

Bart Starr 63.7 (1968)
Eli Manning 66.0 (2019)

QB Rating (Rate)

Bart Starr 105.0 (1966)
Eli Manning 93.6 (2016)

Longest Completed Pass (Lng)

Bart Starr 91 (1960)
Eli Manning 99 (2012)

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Bart Starr

Check/Uncheck

Eli Manning

 

Info

Teams

Bart Starr Green Bay Packers (1956-1971)
Eli Manning New York Giants (2004-2019)

Position

Bart Starr Quarterback
Eli Manning Quarterback

Height

Bart Starr 6'1"
Eli Manning 6'4"

Weight

Bart Starr 197
Eli Manning 218

Drafted

Bart Starr By the Packers in the 17th Round (200th Overall) in the 1956 Draft
Eli Manning By the San Diego Chargers in the 1st Round (1st Overall) in the 2004 Draft

Super Bowls

Super Bowl Wins

Bart Starr 5 (5 NFL Championships 1961-1962, 1965-1967 and 2 Super Bowls I, II)
Eli Manning 2 (XLII, XLVI)

Super Bowl Appearances

Bart Starr 6 (1960-1962, 1965-1967)
Eli Manning 2 (2008, 2012)

Playoff Appearances

Playoff Appearances

Bart Starr 6 (1960-1962, 1965-1967)
Eli Manning 6 (2005-2008, 2011, 2016)

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Bart Starr Yes Inducted in 1977
Eli Manning No Still Playing

NFL MVP

Bart Starr 1 (1966)
Eli Manning 0

Super Bowl MVP

Bart Starr 2 (I, II)
Eli Manning 2 (XLII, XLVI)

Pro Bowl

Bart Starr 4 (1960-1962, 1966)
Eli Manning 4 (2008, 2011, 2012, 2015)

First Team All-Pro

Bart Starr 1 (1966)
Eli Manning 0

NFL Passing Touchdown Leader

Bart Starr 0
Eli Manning 0

NFL Passing Yards Leader

Bart Starr 0
Eli Manning 0

Completion Percentage Leader

Bart Starr 4 (1962, 1966, 1968-1969)
Eli Manning 0

QB Rating Leader

Bart Starr 4 (1964, 1966, 1968-1969)
Eli Manning 0

NFL Offensive Player of the Year

Bart Starr 0
Eli Manning 0

Regular Season Stats

Games (G)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Games Started (GS)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Pass Completions (Cmp)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Passing Attempts (Att)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Completion Percentage (Cmp%)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Passing Yards (Yds)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Touchdown Passes (TD)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Touchdown Percentage (TD%)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Interceptions Thrown (Int)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Interception Percentage (INT%)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Game Winning Drives (GWD)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Yards per Pass Attempt (Y/A)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Adjusted Yards per Pass Attempt (AY/A)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Yards Gained per Pass Completion (Y/C)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Yards Gained per Games Played (Y/G)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

QB Rating (Rate)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Playoff Stats

Games (G)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Games Started (GS)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Pass Completions (Cmp)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Passing Attempts (Att)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Completion Percentage (Cmp%)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Passing Yards (Yds)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Touchdown Passes (TD)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Interceptions Thrown (Int)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

QB Rating (Rate)

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Who do you think is the better player?

Who do you think is the better player?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Filed Under: Player Comparisons, Quarterbacks Tagged With: Bart Starr, Eli Manning

Primary Sidebar

Players

Bart Starr Eli Manning

Related Comparisons

Bart Starr
vs Aaron Rodgersvs Andrew Luckvs Ben Roethlisbergervs Brett Favrevs Cam Newtonvs Dan Foutsvs Dan Marinovs Donovan McNabbvs Drew Breesvs Fran Tarkentonvs Joe Flaccovs Joe Montanavs Joe Namathvs Joe Namathvs John Elwayvs Johnny Unitasvs Kurt Warnervs Matt Ryanvs Michael Vickvs Otto Grahamvs Peyton Manningvs Roger Staubachvs Russell Wilsonvs Steve Youngvs Terry Bradshawvs Tom Bradyvs Tony Romovs Troy Aikman
Eli Manning
vs Daniel Jones vs Aaron Rodgersvs Andrew Luckvs Baker Mayfieldvs Brett Favrevs Cam Newtonvs Carson Palmervs Carson Wentzvs Dak Prescottvs Dan Foutsvs Derek Carrvs Deshaun Watsonvs Donovan McNabbvs Fran Tarkentonvs Jalen Hurtsvs Jameis Winstonvs Jared Goffvs Jimmy Garoppolovs Joe Burrowvs Joe Flaccovs Joe Namathvs Josh Allenvs Justin Herbertvs Kurt Warnervs Kyler Murrayvs Lamar Jacksonvs Marcus Mariotavs Matt Ryanvs Michael Vickvs Mitchell Trubiskyvs Patrick Mahomesvs Peyton Manningvs Roger Staubachvs Russell Wilsonvs Teddy Bridgewatervs Tom Bradyvs Tony Romovs Tua Tagovailoa
NFL Comparisons is not affiliated with the National Football League, NFL, NFL.com or any teams